Menu Changes

Magpie Updates Its Menu For Fall

Magpie's pie
Magpie’s pie Photo: Magpie Artisan Pie Bakery & Boutique

Pumpkin isn’t the only thing going into pies this fall. Holly Ricciardi, who recently opened Magpie Artisan Pie Bakery & Boutique on the 1600 block of South Street, just updated her offerings for the fall, and there are such seasonal ingredients as apples, pears, pecans, and butternut squash going into her sweet and savory pies. Just one leverages the ubiquitous orange gourd-like fruit. The menu lines up five new sweet pies, and three more savory ones. The popular “pie fries” remain, as well as the butterscotch and bourbon beauty that Craig LaBan so enthusiastically endorsed. Keep reading to check out the full menu.

Fall/Winter Menu


Buttery Caramel Apple - 5.50
layers of fresh sweet tart apples enrobed with rich, creamy butter caramel, cinnamon and a hint of pink peppercorn, topped with a light and flaky lattice crust

Ginger Pear Oatmeal Crumb - 5.50
fresh sweet pears, candied ginger and pure vanilla, topped with a ginger, nutmeg, oatmeal crumb

Butterscotch Bourbon Custard - 5
rich, velvety caramelized custard with vanilla and bourbon whiskey

Chocolate Cinnamon Coffee Pecan - 5
deep, rich and chewy filling loaded with callebaut bittersweet chocolate, toasted pecans, cinnamon, and espresso

Praline Streusel Pumpkin - 5
sweet, spiced, creamy pumpkin custard topped with a brown sugar, pecan, candied orange streusel


Black Bean Chorizo Chili Pot Pie- 9.50
spicy black bean Spanish chorizo chili topped with sharp cheddar cheese and Fritos

Smoke Gouda Butternut Squash - 8
tender butternut squash with fresh spinach and smoked gouda topped with toasted walnut bread cumbs

Croque Monsieur
layers of black forest ham, toasted cuded French bread, topped with a creamy gruyere custard

Pie Fries - 3.50
Choose from three different dipping sauces
Bassetts Vanilla Ice Cream - 2


Espresso - 2.25
Americano - 2.50
Cappucinno - 3.50
Latte - 3.70
Pie Latte - 5.00
(comes with a pie fry)
Macchiato - 2.50 House Coffee - 2.25 Tea - 2.25 Tea Latte - 3.00 Extra
Shot - .50 .. .

Coke - 1.75
Diet Coke - 1.75
Milk - 2.00
Iced Coffee -3.00
Iced Latte - 3.50
Bottled Water - 1.50

Magpie Updates Its Menu For Fall