• Intelligencer
  • The Cut
  • Vulture
  • The Strategist
  • Curbed
  • Grub Street
  • Subscribe to the Magazine Give a Gift Subscription Buy Back Issues Current Issue Contents
    Subscribe to New York Magazine
  • Subscribe
  • Profile
    Sign Out
  • Best of New York
  • Cheap Eats
  • Newsletters
  • NYMag.com
  • New York Magazine
  • Intelligencer
  • Vulture
  • The Cut
  • The Strategist
  • Grub Street
  • Curbed
Subscribe Give A Gift
  • Best of New York
  • Cheap Eats
  • Newsletters
  • NYMag.com
  • New York Magazine
  • Intelligencer
  • Vulture
  • The Cut
  • The Strategist
  • Grub Street
  • Curbed
  • Share
  • Tweet
  • Pin It
+Comments Leave a Comment
Cheap Eats
July 8, 2012

How Chefs Are Building a Better Filet-o-Fish

Share

  • Share
  • Tweet
Photo: Danny Kim /New York Magazine

Inspired by Harlem’s fried-fish shacks, Baltimore’s “lake trout” lairs, and, yes, McDonald’s Filet-o-Fish (which turns 50 this year), some notable chefs are treating the undersung sandwich as if it were the new burger or something. Click through the slideshow to see versions from Talde, Eataly, and more.

This story appeared in the July 16, 2012 issue of New York Magazine.

Plus:
• The Cheap List
• A Survey of Pizzaiolo Innovation
• The Bun Explosion
• Asian Hipster Cuisine
• Platt Ranks Dirt-Cheap Meals

View
1 / 7 Photos
Rockaway Boardwalk at Beach 86th St., Rockaway Beach; Friday through Sunday, weather permitting  
            Mexican sandwiches usually come on sturdy bolillo or telera bread. This one capitalizes on the down-market appeal of the Martin’s potato roll, an inspired delivery system for grilled local dogfish, refried beans, cabbage, and smoked-chile mayo. Rockaway Boardwalk at Beach 86th St., Rockaway Beach; Friday through Sunday, weather permitting  
            Mexican sandwiches usually come on sturdy bolillo or telera bread. This one capitalizes on the down-market appeal of the Martin’s potato roll, an inspired delivery system for grilled local dogfish, refried beans, cabbage, and smoked-chile mayo.

Rockaway Boardwalk at Beach 86th St., Rockaway Beach; Friday through Sunday, weather permitting

Mexican sandwiches usually come on sturdy bolillo or...

Rockaway Boardwalk at Beach 86th St., Rockaway Beach; Friday through Sunday, weather permitting

Mexican sandwiches usually come on sturdy bolillo or telera bread. This one capitalizes on the down-market appeal of the Martin’s potato roll, an inspired delivery system for grilled local dogfish, refried beans, cabbage, and smoked-chile mayo.

Rockaway Boardwalk at Beach 96th St., Rockaway Beach  
            It’s Budweiser-battered hake on a roll with lettuce, cabbage, and pickled red onion. Brilliant secret technique: griddling the bread with mayo instead of butter. If you weren’t already 50 feet away from the Atlantic Ocean, this sandwich could take you there. Rockaway Boardwalk at Beach 96th St., Rockaway Beach  
            It’s Budweiser-battered hake on a roll with lettuce, cabbage, and pickled red onion. Brilliant secret technique: griddling the bread with mayo instead of butter. If you weren’t already 50 feet away from the Atlantic Ocean, this sandwich could take you there.

Rockaway Boardwalk at Beach 96th St., Rockaway Beach

It’s Budweiser-battered hake on a roll with lettuce, cabbage, and pickled red onion. Brilliant ...

Rockaway Boardwalk at Beach 96th St., Rockaway Beach

It’s Budweiser-battered hake on a roll with lettuce, cabbage, and pickled red onion. Brilliant secret technique: griddling the bread with mayo instead of butter. If you weren’t already 50 feet away from the Atlantic Ocean, this sandwich could take you there.

Saturdays at Smorgasburg and Sundays at Brooklyn Flea, N. 6th St. at the East River, Williamsburg  
            Four fried-to-order whiting fillets the size of skateboards slapped onto two slices of Texas toast the size of stop signs, a choice of coleslaws, plus all the tartar and hot sauce you want. The motto at Hank’s is “Leave full, leave satisfied,” and they mean it. Saturdays at Smorgasburg and Sundays at Brooklyn Flea, N. 6th St. at the East River, Williamsburg  
            Four fried-to-order whiting fillets the size of skateboards slapped onto two slices of Texas toast the size of stop signs, a choice of coleslaws, plus all the tartar and hot sauce you want. The motto at Hank’s is “Leave full, leave satisfied,” and they mean it.

Saturdays at Smorgasburg and Sundays at Brooklyn Flea, N. 6th St. at the East River, Williamsburg

Four fried-to-order whiting fillets the size of sk...

Saturdays at Smorgasburg and Sundays at Brooklyn Flea, N. 6th St. at the East River, Williamsburg

Four fried-to-order whiting fillets the size of skateboards slapped onto two slices of Texas toast the size of stop signs, a choice of coleslaws, plus all the tartar and hot sauce you want. The motto at Hank’s is “Leave full, leave satisfied,” and they mean it.

369 Seventh Ave., at 11th St., Park Slope; 347-916-0031 (See the Listing)  
            To the panoply of rolls at New York chefs’ disposal, add Hawaiian-style mini-buns. Soft and slightly sweet, they house Dale Talde’s trio of diminutive sandwiches, including one featuring rice‑floured, deep-fried Long Island fluke, accessorized with black‑pepper-vinegar mayo and pickled shallots. 369 Seventh Ave., at 11th St., Park Slope; 347-916-0031 (See the Listing)  
            To the panoply of rolls at New York chefs’ disposal, add Hawaiian-style mini-buns. Soft and slightly sweet, they house Dale Talde’s trio of diminutive sandwiches, including one featuring rice‑floured, deep-fried Long Island fluke, accessorized with black‑pepper-vinegar mayo and pickled shallots.

369 Seventh Ave., at 11th St., Park Slope; 347-916-0031 (See the Listing)

To the panoply of rolls at New York chefs’ disposal, add Hawaiian-style mi...

369 Seventh Ave., at 11th St., Park Slope; 347-916-0031 (See the Listing)

To the panoply of rolls at New York chefs’ disposal, add Hawaiian-style mini-buns. Soft and slightly sweet, they house Dale Talde’s trio of diminutive sandwiches, including one featuring rice‑floured, deep-fried Long Island fluke, accessorized with black‑pepper-vinegar mayo and pickled shallots.

200 Fifth Ave., at 23rd St.; 212-229-2560; Monday through Friday at lunch (See the Listing)  
            Does Italy have a fried-fish-sandwich tradition? Who cares? The catch of the day (recently skate) is wonderfully fresh and beautifully fried, the shallot-and-caper-enhanced tartar homemade, and there’s a refreshing clump of arugula-fennel salad to liven things up. 200 Fifth Ave., at 23rd St.; 212-229-2560; Monday through Friday at lunch (See the Listing)  
            Does Italy have a fried-fish-sandwich tradition? Who cares? The catch of the day (recently skate) is wonderfully fresh and beautifully fried, the shallot-and-caper-enhanced tartar homemade, and there’s a refreshing clump of arugula-fennel salad to liven things up.

200 Fifth Ave., at 23rd St.; 212-229-2560; Monday through Friday at lunch (See the Listing)

Does Italy have a fried-fish-sandwich tradition? Who car...

200 Fifth Ave., at 23rd St.; 212-229-2560; Monday through Friday at lunch (See the Listing)

Does Italy have a fried-fish-sandwich tradition? Who cares? The catch of the day (recently skate) is wonderfully fresh and beautifully fried, the shallot-and-caper-enhanced tartar homemade, and there’s a refreshing clump of arugula-fennel salad to liven things up.

160 Prince St., nr. W. Broadway; 646-556-7720; and 200 Church St., at Thomas St.; 212-309-7555 
            Maury Rubin bakes what should be fried. Falafel for one. Catfish for another—this fillet is generously coated in corn-bread crumbs, crowned with lettuce, and dressed with plenty of sweet housemade mayo spiked with paprika and basil. Half-baked? Hardly. 160 Prince St., nr. W. Broadway; 646-556-7720; and 200 Church St., at Thomas St.; 212-309-7555 
            Maury Rubin bakes what should be fried. Falafel for one. Catfish for another—this fillet is generously coated in corn-bread crumbs, crowned with lettuce, and dressed with plenty of sweet housemade mayo spiked with paprika and basil. Half-baked? Hardly.

160 Prince St., nr. W. Broadway; 646-556-7720; and 200 Church St., at Thomas St.; 212-309-7555

Maury Rubin bakes what should be fried. Falafel for on...

160 Prince St., nr. W. Broadway; 646-556-7720; and 200 Church St., at Thomas St.; 212-309-7555

Maury Rubin bakes what should be fried. Falafel for one. Catfish for another—this fillet is generously coated in corn-bread crumbs, crowned with lettuce, and dressed with plenty of sweet housemade mayo spiked with paprika and basil. Half-baked? Hardly.

160 Havemeyer St., nr. S. 2nd St., Williamsburg; no phone yet; opens this week  
            Former Fette Sau pit master Matt Lang is a Baltimore native and, by definition, an aficionado of that city’s favorite fish, the fried whiting, known for some reason as lake trout. He’s also a fan of the Filet-o-Fish, and his cheese fish sandwich (another Baltimore thing) is an homage to the fast-food archetype right down to the perfectly square Alaskan pollack patty. 160 Havemeyer St., nr. S. 2nd St., Williamsburg; no phone yet; opens this week  
            Former Fette Sau pit master Matt Lang is a Baltimore native and, by definition, an aficionado of that city’s favorite fish, the fried whiting, known for some reason as lake trout. He’s also a fan of the Filet-o-Fish, and his cheese fish sandwich (another Baltimore thing) is an homage to the fast-food archetype right down to the perfectly square Alaskan pollack patty.

160 Havemeyer St., nr. S. 2nd St., Williamsburg; no phone yet; opens this week

Former Fette Sau pit master Matt Lang is a Baltimore native and, by d...

160 Havemeyer St., nr. S. 2nd St., Williamsburg; no phone yet; opens this week

Former Fette Sau pit master Matt Lang is a Baltimore native and, by definition, an aficionado of that city’s favorite fish, the fried whiting, known for some reason as lake trout. He’s also a fan of the Filet-o-Fish, and his cheese fish sandwich (another Baltimore thing) is an homage to the fast-food archetype right down to the perfectly square Alaskan pollack patty.

1 / 7

Tags:

  • cheap eats
  • birdbath bakery
  • cheap eats
  • eataly
  • filet-o-fish
  • lake trout
  • rippers
  • talde
  • slideshow
  • handsome hank
  • motorboat and the big banana
  • More

More Galleries

look book May 26, 2020
The Look Book Goes to The Fly  The socially distanced line for pre-batched martinis and dry-brined chickens in Bed-Stuy. 
By Katy Schneider and Jane Starr Drinkard
gallery Apr. 14, 2019
Chatting With the Singers at the Reopened Winnie’s  The karaoke dive is back in a new space on East Broadway with shiny red booths, a retro-looking mic, and an updated computerized karaoke system. 
By Victor Llorente
Restaurant Review Mar. 13, 2016
Restaurant Review: Momofuku Nishi The chef describes Nishi as a mash-up involving Asian and Italian cuisines, but some experiments make you wonder why anyone would dare tinker with these classics.
By
Underground Gourmet Review Feb. 15, 2016
Llama Inn Is All About New Brooklyn Peruvian Jersey-born first-generation Peruvian-American chef Erik Ramirez is a master of contrast.
By
Restaurant Review Jan. 31, 2016
Restaurant Review: La Chine Chef Kong Khai Meng’s kind of elaborately sourced, “Pan Chinese” hotel cooking is a fairly recent development in the long history of Chinese cuisine
By
Underground Gourmet Review Dec. 6, 2015
Bunk and Southside Coffee Enter New York’s Sandwich Pantheon Bunk is all about the glory that is the sandwich.
By
Gallery Nov. 12, 2015
Dinner for Two in JFK’s Historic TWA Terminal  The former flight attendant and her husband ate recipes prepared from the chefs’ new cookbook. 
By Gillian Duffy
Nov. 10, 2015
See David Bouley Make Dinner for Alice Waters Bouley decided to honor Waters, and the 20th anniversary of her Edible Schoolyard Project, in a way they could mutually appreciate: by cooking a meal.
By
Gallery Nov. 8, 2015
Inside Mission Chinese Food’s Brisket-and-Dumplings Dinner Party for the  The challenge: Create a pop-up restaurant in a theater foyer to feed a starving ensemble — and crew and everyone’s guests — in a manner befitting the years-long hype of the bicoastal restaurant sensation. 
By Gillian Duffy
Gallery Nov. 8, 2015
Inside Mission Chinese Food’s Brisket-and-Dumplings Dinner Party for the  The challenge: Create a pop-up restaurant in a theater foyer to feed a starving ensemble — and crew and everyone’s guests — in a manner befitting the years-long hype of the bicoastal restaurant sensation. 
By
Restaurant Review Oct. 11, 2015
Restaurant Review: Bruno Pizza Along with some very tasty food.
By
Gallery Sept. 3, 2015
How Eli Zabar Transformed an Upper East Side Diner Into an Elegant Wine Bar  A look inside the genteel Eli’s Essentials Wine Bar. 
By Wendy Goodman
Restaurant Review Aug. 23, 2015
Restaurant Review: Babu Ji and Dirt Candy “You’d better give this place three stars,” cried Mrs. Platt in between bites of tandoori-charred rainbow trout and lustrous butter chicken.
By
Restaurant Review Aug. 2, 2015
At Lupulo, the Portuguese-Inspired Cooking Is Almost Too Good for the Setting It’s ambitious food like this that makes you wish George Mendes had decided to open a slightly less expedient casual restaurant.
By
Underground Gourmet Review July 19, 2015
Underground Gourmet Review: A Colombian Expat Forges Her Own Cuisine at Maite In Bushwick, Ella Schmidt cooks gnocchi, arepas, and every local, seasonal vegetable she can get.
By
Cheap Eats July 14, 2015
Why the Bowl Is the Meal of the Moment  They’re healthful, filling, and infinitely customizable, a blank canvas for inventive chefs and fast-casual chains alike. 
By
Cheap Eats July 12, 2015
7 New-Wave, Next-Level Fried-Chicken Sandwiches  Sky-high beef prices and the enduring sandwich craze have laid the groundwork for a new breed of birds on buns. 
By
Burgers May 31, 2015
The 50 Most Important Burgers in New York This town is flooded with high-ambition meat sandwiches. But which is the very best?
By
Gift Guide Nov. 25, 2014
Grub Street’s 2014 Gift Guide: 21 Kitchen Tools for the Home Chef A range of options, big (an 11-piece set of pans designed by Thomas Keller) and small (a rosemary stripper to speed up herb-chopping).
By
Gift Guide Nov. 23, 2014
Grub Street’s 2014 Gift Guide: 24 Unique Finds for the Discerning Gourmand TSA-approved bitters, the Lamborghini of poultry, duck-fat caramels, and more.
By
More Galleries
  • Newsletters
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Media Kit
  • We’re Hiring
  • Press
  • Trademark
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Ad Choices
  • Do Not Sell My Info
Grub Street is a Vox Media Network. © 2021 Vox Media, LLC. All rights reserved.