What to Drink at the Butterfly, Eben Freeman and Michael White's Wisconsin-Style Supper Club

By and
Photo: Victor Prado/New York Magazine

With the arrival of The Butterfly, Eben Freeman and Michael Whites take on a Wisconsin-style supper club, comes that states favorite tipple, the brandy old-fashioneda Badger State bastardization of an old-fashioned old-­fashioned, which tampers with that revered classic by swapping cheap California brandy for whiskey, muddling citrus and maraschino cherries with the bitters and sugar, and sometimes topping the thing with Sprite or 7Up for that fillip of high-fructose delight. In this haute-cocktail age, that simply wont do. Drinks czar Freemans remake subs a vacuum-sealed oleo saccharum (basically a long-macerated citrusy syrup) made from Seville oranges and Washington State cherries for the muddling, and tops up the drink with club soda. He also plans to rescue the sullied reputations of the Tom Collins, the whiskey sour, and the grasshopper. If anyone can do it, he can. 225 W. Broadway, at Franklin St.; no phone yet; May.

*This article originally appeared in the March 25, 2013 issue of New York Magazine.

Related:
This Season's Most Anticipated Eats
Frannys Goes Large-Format