Frank Sinatra was that guy. James Bond is that guy: The guy who can walk into a place and get the thing that nobody else gets... unless you're the guy who knows. Truth is, lots of restaurants have the ability to whip up something special that's not on the menu and not going to be on the menu. But if they'd do it for just anybody, it'd be on the menu, right? Some off-menu items are for customers they already know and value. (Sinatra's was pasta with no garlic, because even Sinatra couldn't get action with bad breath.) Some are for the kind of customer who comes in late, when the staff is already thinking about what they're going to have when they get off, and manages to bond with them as fellow nightowls. And some are just for... that guy, because you know him when you see him. We poked around and talked to some guys and came up with this list of 19 off-menu items which you can have... if you know about them and know how to ask. They tend to be manly dishes, a bit old-school, because that's what that guy is— he exists above trends and fashion. So enter the world of that guy and see what he eats in Chicago in our slideshow below, and then check out our surveys at the other Grub Street cities as well. Because that guy gets around, too.BEGIN SLIDESHOW
Most Viewed Stories
Introducing the J-Cone, New York’s Kookiest New Novelty Ice Cream
It’s Time to Say Good-bye to the Styrofoam Beer Cups of New York
A Diner’s ‘Antonin Scalia Is a Douche’ Brunch Sold Out in Two Hours
Walmart Refused to Make a Confederate-Flag Cake, Happily Made an ISIS One Instead
Adam Platt Ranks 6 of Our Favorite New Tasting Menus
Latest News from Grub StreetYou’ll Soon Be Able to Get Drunk Off Kombucha
An ambitious home-brewer is making beer-bucha happen.This Monstrous Swedish Pizza Is Even Worse Than Hot-Dog Pizza
This latest sacrilege involves a salad and fries.United Airlines Has Figured Out a Way to Turn Food Waste Into Fuel
It's just announced a $30 million investment in carbon-emissions-cutting biofuels.Scientists Say There’s a Link Between Drinking Orange Juice and Getting Skin Cancer
A new study discovered a 36 percent higher risk of melanoma in frequent citrus eaters.Which Fickle-Hipster Beer Should You Be Drinking?
PBR's sales are falling.It’s Time to Say Good-bye to the Styrofoam Beer Cups of New York
The city's upcoming styrofoam ban will effectively end one of the last vestiges of the city's pre-Giuliani years.Walmart Refused to Make a Confederate-Flag Cake, Happily Made an ISIS One Instead
The company says that the employee had no clue it was a terrorist flag.Introducing the J-Cone, New York’s Kookiest New Novelty Ice Cream
The J-Play ice-cream truck specializes in cones made of puffed corn.Check Out This Cheesy Spin on Chicharrón at Rosie’s
Marc Meyer’s riff is less taco and more frico, with lacy shards of baked cheese.Here’s All the Food at Brooks Headley’s Superiority Burger
There's strawberry sorbet, a broccoli salad, and a vegetarian Sloppy Joe.
The company launched it in India.You Can Now Buy ‘Chillary Clinton’ Beer Koozies and a ‘Grillary Clinton’ Spatula
They're available at the presidential candidate's web shop.A Diner’s ‘Antonin Scalia Is a Douche’ Brunch Sold Out in Two Hours
"People were just loving saying it — 'I'll have the Scalia Is a Douche, please.'"The Latest Restaurant in Trouble for Flying a Confederate Flag ... Is in California?
In a historically preserved building, no less.Michael Chernow’s New Seafood Restaurant, Seamore’s, Will Save You the Trip to Montauk
This is the Meatball Shop co-owner's first independent project.Is New York in Danger of Losing Its Most Interesting Beer Boutiques?
Why the retail side of selling unique, small-batch beer remains surprisingly difficult, even at a time when interest in craft beer is at an all-time high.McDonald’s Is Going to Make Its Quarter Pounders Bigger
The patties will have a "new shape," too.Parm Is Donating All Opening-Day Sales From Its Battery Park City Outpost to Chef Eli Kulp
He suffered a serious spinal injury during the May Amtrak derailment.Milk Bar Soho Closed Over the Weekend
It became a casualty of the closing of Band of Outsiders.Adam Platt Ranks 6 of Our Favorite New Tasting Menus
Over the last several months, newly refurbished tasting ateliers, discreet dining bars, and elaborately conceived chef’s menus have been popping up with such frequency that it’s hard to keep track of them all.
Apparently Madonna loves a lemon tart.Meet the New Smorgasburg Vendors Debuting in July
Lebanese-style hummus, honey-whiskey cake, and southern bean cake.Queens Will Get Its First Real Shake Shack Next Year
Danny Meyer's reign continues.Grub Street’s Restaurant Power Rankings: Veggie Burgers, Chicken Sandwiches, and a Lot of Natural Wine
Find out where to eat in our weekly ranking of the city's most-buzzed-about restaurants.Jennifer Lawrence Visits Nobu, Kate Upton Dines at Landmarc
This week's Celebrity Settings.Here Come the Whole Foods Lawsuits
The first was filed a day after New York announced an investigation into the grocer's prices.Brooks Headley’s Veggie-Burger Spot Superiority Burger Is Officially Open
He's set up in the former Dirt Candy space.NBC’s Willie Geist Is Starting to Get the Hang of Homemade Pizza
"On this night, I make a nearly fatal mistake. I forget to put cornmeal on the pizza peel, which allows the pizza to slide smoothly off the long-handled peel and into the oven."Jean-Georges Vongerichten’s Summer Is Off to a Better Start Than Yours
Nice truck, chef.The Coffee Shop of the Future Offers 3-D Printing
There are plans to bring the concept to New York.