How it worked: The chefs were given $50 each, sent to one of three predetermined shopping destinations (Union Square Greenmarket, Eataly, and a Mexican bodega), and told to prepare a picnic using only the ingredients they purchased there, plus pantry staples like salt, pepper, and oil. The picnic spreads were then packed up and whisked off to New York food critic Adam Platt and family for a blind taste test.
Ignacio Mattos, formerly of Isa
Where he shopped: Union Square Greenmarket (17th St. at Broadway; 212-788-7476) What he made: “I didn’t want to do the usual suspects—you know, like sandwiches,” says Mattos, who admitted he struggled to keep the meal both fresh and portable. His gourmet spread included lettuce wraps made with raw beef, shiso, cilantro, and spicy cashew crumble; room-temperature soup with tomato, bell pepper, bread, egg, and basil; rabbit “rillettes” with garlic scapes and mustard; and grilled fava beans, romano beans, and green onions; and roasted rhubarb with fresh cherries, meringue, and goat cheese for dessert. The Platt-family verdict: The Platts applaud the Greenmarket theme of this picnic, but the decoratively charred vegetables are semi-cold when we get them and taste “like tree bark,” according to Daughter No. 1. The tasty stew is also tepid and oddly gummy and could use an accompanying hunk or two of Greenmarket bread. The intricate tartare lettuce wraps aren’t exactly user-friendly, and I’m afraid my kids won’t eat them. The desserts are vinegary and warm when delivered, although they taste great the next day, after twelve hours in the fridge. Scoring: 1 = Packaging: The actual packaging is excellent, but sadly the picnic is brought to us in three paper bags, one of which is grease-stained and about to break. 2 = Ease of use: We like the shiny stew tin, but there’s nowhere to stow our garbage, and there’s nothing in this Greenmarket picnic to drink. 4 = Cooking ingenuity: Forget what the kids say—the tartare lettuce wraps are world-class. 1 = General deliciousness: “Deliciously overwrought” is Mom’s succinct summation. Total=8
Anita Lo of Annisa
Where she shopped: Eataly (200 Fifth Ave., at 23rd St.; 212-229-2560) What she made: “I’m a high-end chef that does a lot of plating, but if you’re doing a picnic, you need things that can be easily packed,” says Lo, whose spread included pork-tonnato sandwiches with sunchokes and fresh arugula; sugar snap peas with chive and basil; a lentil salad with bacon and mustard vinaigrette; and, for dessert, black-pepper shortbread cookies with local strawberries and Meyer lemon–ricotta dip. Money—or rather the lack thereof—presented the biggest challenge. “Eataly’s great, don’t get me wrong,” says Lo, “but it sure is expensive.” The Platt-family verdict: “This is the most tidy picnic of all,” says Daughter No. 1, and we all agree. We like the functional (if slightly generic) picnic basket, and the fact that it keeps everything inside neatly packed and cool. We like the water bottle, too, although we wish there were two of them (along with some bubbly Italian sodas). The messy, overly rich pork-tonnato sandwiches sound great in theory (especially to Dad), but we’d prefer fresh bread, cheese, and that fabulous Eataly salumi. The side dishes and dessert work better (especially the tangy, pork-larded lentils, and the strawberries and cream), even if we’ve seen them a hundred times before. Scoring: 4 = Packaging: “We need one of these baskets, Dad,” says Daughter No. 2. 3 = Ease of use: The sandwiches were a mess, and we could have used another water bottle and some cups. 0 = Cooking ingenuity: “This is what $50 gets you at Eataly?” asks Dad. 2 = General deliciousness: A good sandwich is the key to a fine picnic, and we didn’t get one here. One point for the side dishes, however, and another for the dessert. Total: 9
Justin Warner of Do or Dine
Where he shopped: Zarazoga (215 Ave. A, nr. 14th St.; 212-780-9204) What he made: “It’s not attempting to be a Michelin basket—it’s a freaking picnic,” says Warner of his laid-back but inventive spread, which included tortilla chips with “fall-apart good” tongue pâté and mango-and-black-bean salsa; a salad of underripe tomato and nopales; a torta sandwich with veal, chorizo mayo, and huitlacoche; and a “bonkers” creamy guava gel for dessert. In the end, Warner had ingredients to spare. The Platt-family verdict: A good picnic should be nourishing, functional, and full of surprises, and this one has all of those things. The girls can’t decide what they enjoy more: the crunchy fresh-made corn chips or the packing crate, which doubles as a stool to sit on when the bugs arrive. Sergeant Mom likes the jauntily written menu-map, which tells us what the dishes are and when to eat them. Dad likes a dose of classic huitlacoche, or “corn smut,” anywhere he can get it, and we all approve of the old-style, south-of-the-border Coca-Colas for a sweet finish. Scoring: 5 = Packaging: Sure, you have to carry the packing crate with two hands, but it’s worth the effort, provided you’re not on a jungle hike. 4 = Ease of use: The lighter attached to our Cokes with tape made for a clever bottle opener. 5 = Cooking ingenuity: Dad wasn’t wild about the tongue pâté, but he appreciated the effort. 4 = General deliciousness: One point each for the chips and mango salsa, the tomato salad, the sandwich, and the curiously refreshing guava-gel dessert. Total: 18 Winner!
Most Viewed Stories
Here Are the 2015 Michelin Stars for New York City
Trouble on East 65th Street: Why Does Daniel Keep Losing Stars?
New York’s Best New Bakery Is Located in an Office-Building Lobby
Hong Kong McDonald’s Rolls Out a Mysterious ‘Batman’ Burger
Here’s an 8,000-Calorie Breakfast That Requires a Signed Waiver to Eat
Momofuku Milk Bar Soho Opens TomorrowAll openings »
Looks Like Krescendo Has Served Its Last PizzaAll closings »
Search by name
Or, search by
Latest News on Grub StreetSurge Pricing Is Coming for Your Meal Deliveries Next
This way, eating at mealtimes can cost you even more.Is This App-Connected Frying Pan the Future, or Just Another Stupid Gadget?
Judging by its crowd-funding so far, the latter.Europe’s Most Celebrated Bartender Will Mix Drinks in New York Next Week
If you're going to pay $17 for a cocktail, why not pay $17 for one made by one of the best?Lena Dunham and Amy Schumer Agree: Deep-Frying Makes Everything Better
That includes vaginas.Watch Chris Cosentino’s Truly Excellent Talk on the Perils of the Celebrity-Chef Lifestyle
"'You've got really good sound bites.' I f--king hate that word."Dunkin’ Donuts’ Customers Use Twice As Much Wi-Fi As Starbucks’
Talk about bandwidth.Even Conservatives Support a Wage Hike for Restaurant Workers
Meanwhile, the city's minimum wage will most likely reach $15.22 per hour in five years.Introducing Emmett’s No-Ketchup-Allowed Chicago Dog
The deep-dish pizza purveyors are courting culinary controversy again.Trouble on East 65th Street: Why Does Daniel Keep Losing Stars?
The chef needs to figure out how to please critics, inspectors, and list-voters whose tastes practically demand forward-thinking cuisine while simultaneously pleasing his regular clientele.Joël Robuchon Will Open His Comeback Restaurant in Lower Manhattan
This time he's got a whopping 11,000 square feet.
Plus doughnuts and "other three dimensional shapes," too.Here Are the 2015 Michelin Stars for New York City
Daniel lost a star, Blanca gained one, and Chef's Table at Brooklyn Fare remains on top.Rage Against the Machine Is Now Just Raging Against a Neighborhood Café
"Rock stars don't get special treatment at The 5 Point. We couldn't give less of a shit."New York’s Best New Bakery Is Located in an Office-Building Lobby
How did a talented bread man end up opening a fantastic new bakery in the lobby of 40 Worth Street?McDonald’s Japan Rolls Out Its Own Black Cheeseburger
There is also a white chicken sandwich.The Not-So-New Guy: Chef Jamie Bissonnette’s Big Year in New York
"New York started off by punching me in the face, but now it's giving me a hug."The 11 Strangest Starbucks Locations on the Planet
You can get the chain's frappuccinos at a funeral home, at the Louvre, and also at Guantánamo Bay.Here’s an 8,000-Calorie Breakfast That Requires a Signed Waiver to Eat
Customers "see it come out on the big platter all heaped high and start to cry."Celebrity Chefs Gina and Pat Neely Are Divorcing
"Our focus will be on our individual brands," they write.Enrique Olvera’s Anticipated Restaurant Cosme Now Accepts Reservations
Service begins the last week in October, apparently.
Nothing says vigilante justice like Squeezy Cheesy Fries with a Sparkling Green Apple Tea on the side.Grand Banks Will Close Out the Season With Hot Toddies, Clam Chowder, and $1 Oysters
Also, there's an oyster happy hour.This Restaurant Gives a Gun Discount to Customers Who Prove They’re Armed
"As long as everybody has a gun we're all the same size," the owner says.How Nobu’s Most Famous Dish Helped Launch a Global Restaurant Empire
Black cod with miso was effectively the Momofuku pork bun of its day.Here’s Where to Get Free (or Very Cheap) Coffee Today
Free samples, $1 cups, and buy-one-get-one deals galore.The Amy’s Baking Company Couple Is Back, Threatening to Stab Someone
"You're going to go to jail for the rest of your life," an onlooker said.Restaurant Review: At elan, Downtown-Dining Pioneer David Waltuck Dates Himself
Shouldn't this eagerly awaited new Flatiron venture feel slightly more contemporary?Some Brave Soul Vowed to Spend 49 Days Eating Nothing But Olive Garden Pasta
This guy is like the Charles Lindbergh of rigatoni.The Restaurant From Mystic Pizza Apparently Owes $100K in Back Wages
The now-famous pizza spot paid employees as little as $5.69 an hour.You Can Buy the Post Office’s Famous-Chef Stamps Today
One for James Beard, Julia Child, Edna Lewis, Joyce Chen, and Felipe Rojas-Lombardi.
Find out where to eat in Grub Street's weekly ranking of the city's most-buzzed-about restaurants.World’s Most Awesome Woman Celebrates 102nd Birthday With White Castle Blowout
"One of these days I'll ask them how they make that hamburger."Hillary Clinton Fund-raises at ACME; Leonardo DiCaprio Parties at Space Ibiza
This week's Celebrity Settings.City’s ‘First Bar for Pregnant Women’ Is, Thankfully, Just a Publicity Stunt
Their marketing concepts should have gestated a little longer.Closed Doughnut Shop Mysteriously Promises to Reopen Without ‘the Skunk’
At least one former customer is pretty sure they're talking about a manager.Norah O’Donnell Loves Bacon and Baklava
"More bacon for me!"Marilyn Hagerty’s Long-Awaited Applebee’s Review Is Finally Here
"Menu is extensive and takes study if you are not a regular here."A Belgian Town Is Building an Underground Beer Pipeline — What Could Go Wrong?
Townspeople have no doubt already devised ways to tap it.America’s Fastest-Growing Restaurant Chain Is a Breastaurant Called Twin Peaks
Founding motto: "Hooters just wasn't racy enough."The Neo-Dives: 9 Bars That Keep New York’s Downscale Drinking Tradition Alive
A proper dive takes decades of stasis and neglect, but these bars are all spots to go if you just want a watering hole that's adverse to anything too fancy.
The colossal group of vendors will be indoors from November 8 until March.Wendy’s New Business Plan: Just Put Pulled Pork on Everything
"From their point of view, they think they can oven roast a bunch of pork, slather it in sauce, and idiots will come."12 New Places to Try for Your Next Great Pizza Experience
Marta, GG's, B-Side, and more.Saveur’s New Editor-in-Chief on His Plans for the Storied Magazine
"To me, it seems like the most exciting opportunity in food media right now."The Obamas Ate Burrata and Croquettes at Estela Last Night
The president also had some fluke carpaccio and endive salad.Marta Chef Nick Anderer Explains His Surf-and-Turf Take on Saltimbocca
Herby, salty, and faintly smoky.Chinese Restaurant Tests Innovative New Menu Item: Drug-Laced Noodles
An owner dosed his food with the same ingredient used to make opium.Maison Premiere Team Opening Second Restaurant in Williamsburg
The project will open next year.Emeril Lagasse Laments ‘All the Obama Nonsense’
"I'm just saying ... the government should stay out of things."Popeyes’ New ‘Beer Can’ Chicken Is a Travesty
Except it's fried, and it has zero beer.