If there's one thing New York is not short on, it's sandwiches. From the bodega across the street to the fancy sandwiches peppering the boroughs, it seems like we have it all. However, one can never have too many sandwiches, so a couple of national chains have moved on in to join the city's sandwich scene. Earl of Sandwich and Potbelly's both arrived in New York this summer and have already started expanding. It's easy to see why they're doing well. But are they any good? We decided we needed to grab a man who knew his way around a sandwich and have him decide. Enter No. 7 Sub's Tyler Kord, the man who has even managed to elevate humble bologna into a special meal between bread. We set out with Tyler, and an open mind, to see if the featured sandwiches at these chains are worthy of your lunchtime dollars.
Earl of Sandwich: The Full Montagu
Roast beef, turkey, Swiss cheese, Cheddar, lettuce, roma tomato, and "the Earl's mustard sauce."
Tyler came into the first Earl sandwich with high hopes after reading the description: "That sounds like a party. A sandwich party." He was pleased with the amount of meat included for the $5.99 price tag, but found that even with all those ingredients, it basically tasted like a hot dog. A "salty as balls" hot dog.
Earl of Sandwich: Italian
Salami, capicola, roasted ham, mortadella, mozzarella, roma tomato, and "zesty Italian dressing."
Earl's Italian tasted overwhelmingly of pepperoni, despite pepperoni not being an ingredient in the sandwich. "It tastes like a good slice of pepperoni pizza, crossed with a Hot Pocket. In a good way." Tyler found the bread portion "inoffensive, which in sandwiches is a good thing."
Earl of Sandwich: The Original 1762
Roast beef, Cheddar, and "creamy horseradish sauce."
This was the clear winner of the three Earl's sandwiches we tried. "I can actually tell what I'm eating!" Tyler said. "It tastes like roast beef, which is nice." It had an "Arby's flavor profile" (a good thing, as Tyler loves Arby's), but the meat was clearly beef, and not meat-flavored "sawdust, like at Arby's." However, the meat had some rainbow action on it, which is nice in the sky but not what you want to see on your beef.
Potbelly: Roast Beef
"Thin-sliced" beef and provolone.
Potbelly's roast beef disappointed as soon as it was unwrapped, and made it clear why the chain offers an "extra meat" option — the sandwich had just an ounce of roast beef on it (for comparison, a bodega sandwich usually has three or four ounces). It also had no taste. "This could literally be any protein. It could even be tofu, or seitan to get the texture right." The lack of flavor turned out to be what Tyler found most surprising, explaining that with all the chemicals at the disposal of factory farms, they could make their products taste like "unicorn meat" if they wanted to. Sadly, there were no unicorn horns on display at Potbelly.
Potbelly: The Italian
Capicola, mortadella, salami, pepperoni, and provolone cheese.
Potbelly's Italian, unlike Earl's, did not taste solely of pepperoni. "It tastes the most like what you could get at a bodega, which is the ultimate sandwich in a way. It's kind of the standard." It definitely didn't need a purchase of extra meat; however, there was so much grease that eating more than a bite or two seemed like too much. "I'd pay extra to not eat that," Kord told us. A shame, because this would have been the winning Potbelly sandwich if not for the explosion of oil.
Potbelly: A Wreck
Salami, roast beef, turkey, ham, and Swiss cheese.
Another signature sandwich, another sandwich that tasted like a hot dog. Unfortunate, because this was the one we had heard the best things about from Midwestern friends. "This tastes like something people in the Midwest would love, but we live in New York," responded Tyler. The Wreck also suffered from lack of meat, but was the tastiest of the Potbelly bunch.
Most Viewed Stories
Doctor Who’s Cast Reacts to New York’s Newest Doctor Who-Themed Café
Ketchup vs. Catsup: Why Heinz Is Irreplaceable
Korean Barbecue Specialist Kang Ho Dong Baekjeong Will Open Manhattan Location This Fall
You’re Not Imagining It: Starbucks Is Literally Following You
Here’s the Ramen Burger, on Sale at Smorgasburg This Saturday
Search by name
Or, search by
Latest News on Grub StreetMaison Premiere’s Labor Day Party; The Pines Teams Up With Table on Ten
Today's Leftovers.The Restaurateur Who Made Servers Pay Diner’s Credit-Card Fees Had a Sudden Change of Heart
"We have always listened to our guests and our community," said Blue Plate owner David Burley.Whole Foods and Trader Joe’s Nut Butters Included in Wide-Reaching Recall
Perhaps your PB&Js should just be Js for a while .Here’s the Full List of Competing Cooks on Top Chef’s New Season
Richard Blais joins the 16 new contestants as a guest judge.Yuji Ramen Will Pop Up at Okonomi Beginning Next Week
This is great news for fans of Yuji Haraguchi's inventive noodle dishes.You’re Not Imagining It: Starbucks Is Literally Following You
The company has announced the launch of food trucks.Crumbs Bake Shop Chain Closer to Reopening, Possibly Now With Dippin’ Dots
Just $6.5 million for 27 stores. A bargain?Here’s Some Jägermeister-Sauced Poutine Served in an Old Bottle
Plus, Canada gets its "very first 100% bacon sausage Hot Dog."NYC Proposes Banning Toys From Unhealthy Fast-Food Kids’ Meals
Less than one percent of kids’ meal combinations met recommended government nutrition standards, according to a recent study.Judge Temporarily Halts Subway Inn’s Eviction Proceedings
"We know that this is just the first step in a very long and hard David Vs. Goliath Fight."
This week's roundup.Watch a Clip From the New Season of Mind of a Chef
"I treat this piece of wood with a lot of respect," he says.No. 7’s Birthday Party; the Cleveland’s New Large-Format Options
Today's Leftovers.Tiny Indiana Town Despises Oreo for Sending Them Lots of Tiny Cookies
"Why in the world would they ship out one mini cookie is beyond me."Korean Barbecue Specialist Kang Ho Dong Baekjeong Will Open Manhattan Location This Fall
There's a Momofuku vet in the kitchen, too.Spiking Booze With Straight Viagra Predictably Ends in Entrepreneur’s Arrest
The Viagra and booze bootlegger described his concoction as a "nutritional healthy liquor."Doctor Who’s Cast Reacts to New York’s Newest Doctor Who-Themed Café
Guess Who's coming to dinner, indeed.Bakery That Supplied Crumbs Laid Off 75 Workers After Cupcake-Bubble Bust
Standing orders for 225,000 cupcakes per week suddenly dropped 100,000 just below the closure.Café Owner Told Job Applicant ‘Coffee Culture Is More About White People’
Outraged patrons stormed out in protest.Slaughterhouse Owners Allegedly Ordered Employees to Process Meat From Cancer-Stricken Cows
They allegedly put healthy heads on diseased cattle to fool inspectors.
Cherche Midi's fries are perfect. Its fancy-ass ketchup is not.Rose’s Luxury, High Street on Market, Estela Named ‘Best New Restaurants’
Bon Appétit released its annual Hot 10 list.Burst Pipe Temporarily Closes the Modern
It'll be back up and running in no time.Lobster Bash at Jeffrey’s Grocery; Back Forty’s Crab-a-Palooza
Today's Leftovers.Restaurant Owner Isn’t Sure Why Everyone Hated Her Nazi-Themed Spaghetti
"Long Live Nazi Spaghetti" had its share of critics.Taco Bell Gives America $1 Normcore Burritos
The Doritos Loco dust has apparently settled.100 Montaditos Will Give Away Free Sandwiches Tomorrow
And they have more than 100 of them to hand out.Golden Cadillac Will Reopen As Boilermaker Next Month
The on-tap Zombie made with three kinds of rum is classified as "cool & refreshing" on the menu. This is going to be fun.Cambridge Needs an Intrepid Student to Study a Lot of Chocolate
Your life really can be life a box of chocolates.The Seinfeld Restaurant Is Pretty Meh About Accommodating Customers in Wheelchairs
"We have tables outside, though, that they can use."
Just don't ask your barista for the secret, off-menu Pumpkin Spice Latte chardonnay.A South Korean Restaurant Banned ‘Africans’ Over Nonexistent Ebola Risk
The owner quickly reversed the policy.Watch Jimmy Fallon and David Chang Have a Hot-Wing-Eating Contest
It's the Tonight Show showdown you knew was coming.Freemans’ Ten-Year Anniversary; Left Bank’s Oyster Dinner
Today's Leftovers.The East Village’s First Rice-Burger Shop Opens on Monday
Wasabi salt!Albert Trummer’s New South Beach Bar Sounds Even Nuttier Than Apotheke
The creator of "fantastic medicinal cocktails" is at it again.Arrested McDonald’s Worker Sues News Station That Posted Her Personal Data
Debra Harrell is suing the station.Take a Look Around Stieber’s Sweet Shoppe, a Charming New Candy Store on Bleecker Street
Over 400 kinds of candy!Grub Street’s Restaurant Power Rankings: Grand Banks, Dimes, and More
Find out where to eat in Grub Street's weekly ranking of the city's most-buzzed-about restaurants.Shake Shack May Be Gearing Up for an IPO
Yes, dividends do come with those fries (and that shake).
A jar containing at least 50 hazelnuts is sold every 2.5 seconds.A ‘Billion’ Oysters May Help Protect Staten Island from Future Floods
"They reduce water velocity, they reduce erosion of the shoreline and they reduce the height and intensity of the waves."Taylor Swift Stops at the Smile; Pink Hangs at the Surf Lodge
This week's installment of Celebrity Settings.A Restaurant Nearly Killed a Grandmother With Toxic Sweet Tea
An employee mistook lye for sugar.Cocktail Icon Julie Reiner Makes Her Daiquiris With Smuggled Cuban Rum
"We brought a half-bottle of Moet rosé and drank that from plastic cups."The Rise of New York’s Grand, Glorious Modern Food Halls
Food halls and markets are quickly becoming both vendors' and diners' preferred places for assembling some of New York's very best food.Dominique Ansel Teams Up With DKNY; Blue Ribbon Brooklyn’s Oyster Tasting
Today's Leftovers.Starbucks Is Finally Testing Cold-Brew Coffee
There's a limited run going on at Boston-area locations.Why 70,000 Environmentalists Are Fighting the elBulli Museum
It encroaches on a "protected area."People Wasted a Demoralizing Amount of Time Watching Arby’s 13-Hour Brisket Ad
An average of 38 minutes per person, to be exact.