If there's one thing New York is not short on, it's sandwiches. From the bodega across the street to the fancy sandwiches peppering the boroughs, it seems like we have it all. However, one can never have too many sandwiches, so a couple of national chains have moved on in to join the city's sandwich scene. Earl of Sandwich and Potbelly's both arrived in New York this summer and have already started expanding. It's easy to see why they're doing well. But are they any good? We decided we needed to grab a man who knew his way around a sandwich and have him decide. Enter No. 7 Sub's Tyler Kord, the man who has even managed to elevate humble bologna into a special meal between bread. We set out with Tyler, and an open mind, to see if the featured sandwiches at these chains are worthy of your lunchtime dollars.
Earl of Sandwich: The Full Montagu
Roast beef, turkey, Swiss cheese, Cheddar, lettuce, roma tomato, and "the Earl's mustard sauce."
Tyler came into the first Earl sandwich with high hopes after reading the description: "That sounds like a party. A sandwich party." He was pleased with the amount of meat included for the $5.99 price tag, but found that even with all those ingredients, it basically tasted like a hot dog. A "salty as balls" hot dog.
Earl of Sandwich: Italian
Salami, capicola, roasted ham, mortadella, mozzarella, roma tomato, and "zesty Italian dressing."
Earl's Italian tasted overwhelmingly of pepperoni, despite pepperoni not being an ingredient in the sandwich. "It tastes like a good slice of pepperoni pizza, crossed with a Hot Pocket. In a good way." Tyler found the bread portion "inoffensive, which in sandwiches is a good thing."
Earl of Sandwich: The Original 1762
Roast beef, Cheddar, and "creamy horseradish sauce."
This was the clear winner of the three Earl's sandwiches we tried. "I can actually tell what I'm eating!" Tyler said. "It tastes like roast beef, which is nice." It had an "Arby's flavor profile" (a good thing, as Tyler loves Arby's), but the meat was clearly beef, and not meat-flavored "sawdust, like at Arby's." However, the meat had some rainbow action on it, which is nice in the sky but not what you want to see on your beef.
Potbelly: Roast Beef
"Thin-sliced" beef and provolone.
Potbelly's roast beef disappointed as soon as it was unwrapped, and made it clear why the chain offers an "extra meat" option — the sandwich had just an ounce of roast beef on it (for comparison, a bodega sandwich usually has three or four ounces). It also had no taste. "This could literally be any protein. It could even be tofu, or seitan to get the texture right." The lack of flavor turned out to be what Tyler found most surprising, explaining that with all the chemicals at the disposal of factory farms, they could make their products taste like "unicorn meat" if they wanted to. Sadly, there were no unicorn horns on display at Potbelly.
Potbelly: The Italian
Capicola, mortadella, salami, pepperoni, and provolone cheese.
Potbelly's Italian, unlike Earl's, did not taste solely of pepperoni. "It tastes the most like what you could get at a bodega, which is the ultimate sandwich in a way. It's kind of the standard." It definitely didn't need a purchase of extra meat; however, there was so much grease that eating more than a bite or two seemed like too much. "I'd pay extra to not eat that," Kord told us. A shame, because this would have been the winning Potbelly sandwich if not for the explosion of oil.
Potbelly: A Wreck
Salami, roast beef, turkey, ham, and Swiss cheese.
Another signature sandwich, another sandwich that tasted like a hot dog. Unfortunate, because this was the one we had heard the best things about from Midwestern friends. "This tastes like something people in the Midwest would love, but we live in New York," responded Tyler. The Wreck also suffered from lack of meat, but was the tastiest of the Potbelly bunch.
Most Viewed Stories
Ben Lyons Tries to Eat Chinese Food Every Sunday Night
Horrific Animal Cruelty Exposed at Farm for Domino’s and Pizza Hut Cheese Provider
I Pumpkin Spiced My Life With Black-Market Starbucks Syrup
Inside the World’s Most Mysterious Nutella Emporium
Neil Patrick Harris Lunches at Landmarc; SJP Dines at Acme
Inside the World’s Most Mysterious Nutella EmporiumAll openings »
Looks Like Krescendo Has Served Its Last PizzaAll closings »
Search by name
Or, search by
Latest News on Grub StreetBurger King Japan’s Black Burgers Are Even Worse in Real Life
Some people say it has a mysterious "peppery" taste, too.How to Get Ample Hills Ice Cream Delivered Right to Your Home
"Classics" include Peppermint Pattie and the shop's famed Salted Crack Caramel flavor.Just What You Never Wanted: Airline Food Delivered Directly to Your House
Make sure your seatbacks and tray tables are in their fully upright and locked positions, and you have plenty of sriracha sauce.The Grub Street Food Festival Is Back on October 5
Roberta's and Doughnut Plant lead the pack of vendors this year out.Grub Street’s Restaurant Power Rankings: GG’s Opens, the Modern Returns, and More
Find out where to eat in Grub Street's weekly ranking of the city's most-buzzed-about restaurants.America’s Beloved PBR Will Be Sold to Russian Brewers
"America's Best in 1893" gets foreign owners in 2014.Now Olive Garden’s Employees Are Threatening to Strike
They want executives and shareholders to know they have issues, too.Neil Patrick Harris Lunches at Landmarc; SJP Dines at Acme
This week's Celebrity Settings.2014 Is on Track to Be the Best Year Yet for White Truffles
A lot rain and a lot of warmth make for a bumper are good for the fungus.Ben Lyons Tries to Eat Chinese Food Every Sunday Night
"I had a glass of wine at lunch because it made me feel European."
The restaurant corporation apologized to Vietnamese Americans who were "hurt and offended."Scottish Bars Where You Can Watch Tonight’s Referendum Voting Results
Including Highlands and St. Andrews.Blue Bottle Has Launched Its New Coffee-Delivery Service
They're completing their acquisition of Tonx.Why It’s Time to Start Eating Tibetan Yak Cheese
"We call every day," Ripert says. "They say, 'maybe tomorrow.'"Here’s a Restaurant That Rewards Customers Who Give It Bad Yelp Reviews
Haters get 25 percent off and free cooking classes.The Cotton-Candy Ice-Cream Cone Is Now a Reality
S'mores ice cream plus sugar cone plus smoked cotton-candy.Horrific Animal Cruelty Exposed at Farm for Domino’s and Pizza Hut Cheese Provider
Video shows workers punching and shocking cows.Check Out This Marvelous S’mores Espresso Drink
It required a month of testing to perfect.Why Tartine Breadmaster Chad Robertson Is Going Global
He's expanding.Inside the World’s Most Mysterious Nutella Emporium
"We'll keep to first names for now."
Yes, "misogyny is alive and well" in the service industry.It Only Took America 80 Years to Turn Bloody Marys Into a Complete Joke
Congratulations, everyone.Tom Colicchio’s Next TV Show Will Be ‘Completely Different’ From Top Chef
"I’m laboring over this, because I want to get it right."People Are Not Happy With the ‘Communist’ Logo at Taco Bell’s Bánh Mì Offshoot
"You're just insulting Vietnamese Americans by associating Saigon with the communist symbol."Dominique Ansel Will Open in Tokyo in 2015
"There will be something created just for Tokyo, and I will personally see every aspect of development," the chef says.Krispy Kreme Has Limited-Edition Ghostbusters-Themed Doughnuts
With Slimer and Stay-Puft, of course.A Restaurant Somehow Thought an Adrian Peterson ‘Spank Your Server’ Promo Was a Good Idea
The owner calls it "a bad joke gone awry."Manhattan Takes Its Next Step Toward Becoming One Enormous Shake Shack Line
Hope you like crinkle-cut French fries.Here’s the Scene at Today’s Opening of a Real-Life Friends Central Perk
Free coffee, and one special orange couch.GG’s, the Goat Town Reboot, Will Serve Oven-Baked Lobster and Grandma-Style Pizza
It's the Goat Town reboot.
Il Buco Alimentari's new executive chef Roger Martinez on the changes he has planned. (Don't worry: The short ribs are staying put.)Walmart Told Customers a Fake ‘Sugar Tax’ Was Making Their Coke Cost More
The "tax" equaled the amount discounted by an ad.This Coffee Start-up Uses Whiskey Instead of Water in Its Cold Brew
It's clearly an idea whose time has come.Kobayashi Battles the Tiny Hamster in the Eating Contest You’ve Eagerly Awaited
It's like Ali versus Frazier, but with hot dogs.Group Reconsiders Plans for a Pop-up That Only Serves Death Row Last Meals
It offered all of the culinary perks "without the nasty execution bit."I Pumpkin Spiced My Life With Black-Market Starbucks Syrup
One man's quest to make everything taste like a latte.The Rainbow Room Finally Reopens October 6
The Art Deco landmark is back.Bidding Is Up to $100K on eBay for NFL Player’s 20-Cent Tip Receipt
Six figures for a glorified autograph.OddFellows Launches Delivery in Manhattan
Right in time for the cold weather.Will These 20 Food-Porn Photos Make You Feel Less Hungry?
According to a new study, they might!
A ten-ouncer you can hold in the palm of your hand.Corporate Executives Defend Olive Garden’s Unlimited Breadsticks
"The Outlook for the Future Is Bright."6 Dishes From a ‘Weird Chinese Food’ Dinner That Mostly Just Sound Delicious
Duck gizzards, pig ears, and thousand-year eggs.Surge — the World’s Most Nineties Soda — Is Coming Back
The revived brand will be sold in 12-packs available only on Amazon.What to Eat at Marta, Danny Meyer’s Brand-New Pizzeria
Pizza, beer-brined chicken, and more pizza.Fall Fruit: 16 Spots to Hit If You’re Looking for Fresh Figs
With foie gras, quail, ricotta, and, of course, honey.A Pizza Hut Horrified Animal Lovers With Free Pets for People Who Bought Pizzas
The offending store concedes it was probably a "bad idea."An Ice Cream Shop Rolled Out ‘Big Straight Ice Cream’ This Weekend
"What's the issue? We can call our ice cream whatever we want," the wine bar's manager says.Restaurant Review: At Wilma Jean, the Southern Chef Surrenders to New York's Fried-Chicken Fixation
Plus: Hanamizuki serves up fusion omusubi in a serene setting.California Makes It Illegal to Sue People for Posting Nasty Yelp Reviews
The first, and probably not last, state to do this.