The Soda Shop opened back in 2006 to fill the city’s authentic egg-cream void, but this fall’s grumpy economy seems to have triggered a comforting soda-fountain revival. Sam Mason revealed he’s brainstorming adult floats, Sweetiepie intends to be a nostalgic ice-cream mecca, and Rob and Robin just stepped off a root-beer trail. If you’re looking for more nouveau fountain eats before the latest ventures open, you can pop into retro-minded dessert bar Mama’s Mudsliders. Pastry chef Hali Horn serves frozen banana custard and birch-beer floats next to hot apple beignets and deconstructed S’mores Popsicles. Take a look at her fall menu after the jump.
SALTY
BLT $7.50
Thick cut bacon, romaine lettuce, tomatoes, and our garlic aioli served on rye bread
Chicken Salad $7.50
Homemade chicken salad w/ lettuce, tomato, and onion on wheat bread
Grilled Cheese $6.50
A mix of Mountain Valley sharp cheddar and mozzarella served on sourdough bread
Add tomato / bacon / sautéed onions add $2 each
Ham and Cheese $7.50
Black forest ham, baby Swiss cheese, yellow mustard, lettuce and tomato on rye bread
Grilled Vegetable $7
Served cold with goat cheese and balsamic vinaigrette
on baguette
Peanut Butter and Jelly $5
Smooth or chunky peanut butter and grape or strawberry jelly on white bread
Peanut Butter, Bananas and Honey $5.50
Served on white bread
All sandwiches served with a side salad / chips
Cheese Plates:
Traditional $12 Adventurous $15
French Fries $6
Choice of 3 Dipping Sauces
Garlic Aioli/ Ketchup/ Mayo/Honey Balsamic/ Blue Cheese
($1 for Extra Sauce)
Cheese Fries $7
Spicy Cheese Fries $7.50
Pickle Plate:
1-2 People $5 3-4 People $9
Home Made Potato Chips $3
SWEET
(All Desserts & Ice Creams Are Made In House)
Frozen Banana Custard $8
Caramel Walnut Sauce
Fried Peanut Butter & Jelly or Peanut Butter, Banana, Honey Sandwich $6
Butterscotch Pudding $7
with Whipped Cream and Vanilla Cookie
Spiced Bread Pudding $8
with Maple Whipped Cream
S’mores Popsicle $8
Toasted Marshmallow Custard & Homemade Graham Cracker Bits Dipped in Chocolate
Beignets $8 or Plain $5
Fresh Doughnuts filled with Chocolate , Vanilla or
Apple & Whipped Cream
Signature Mudpie $10
5 Layers of Chocolate and Coffee Decadence
Inside-Out Carrot Cake $8
Lemon Cream Cheese Frosting
Apple Crisp $7 (with Ice Cream $9)
Ice Cream $6
Vanilla Bean/ Chocolate/ Coffee/ Peanut Butter / Strawberry
Brownie $6 (add Ice Cream $8)
with Crème Fraiche Whipped Cream
Ice Cream Sundae $9
Chocolate or Caramel Sauce / Nuts / Pretzels / Whipped Cream / Add Banana $1
Jello Mold $8
Cranberry and Marshmallow goodness
Brownie Sandwich $7
Peanut Butter Ice Cream
Milk & Cookies $8
your choice of 3 cookies & milk: whole, skim, soy or goat
Chocolate Chip / Oatmeal Raisin /
Peanut Butter Chip / Graham Cracker
Apricot Mocha Cake $9
BEVERAGES
Cold
Mudslider $8
Chocolate Espresso Soda with Chocolate
and Coffee Ice Cream
Flight of Floats $10
Choose 3 of the following:
Strawberry Vanilla
Chocolate Peanut Butter
Cinnamon
Anise Coffee
Apple Cream
Chocolate Mint
Birch Beer Float $6
Creamsicle $7
Fresh Orange Juice with our Vanilla Ice Cream
Black & White $8
Flavored Soda $4
(please ask your server for today’s flavors)
Egg Cream $4
Chocolate / Vanilla / Strawberry
Southampton $3
Tonic with Key Lime Juice & Bitters
Milk $3
Whole / Skim / Soy / Goat
Chocolate Milk $4
Whole / Skim / Soy / Goat
Milk Shake $7
Chocolate / Vanilla / Strawberry / Coffee / Peanut Butter
Malt $8
Chocolate / Vanilla / Strawberry / Coffee / Peanut Butter
Iced Coffee $5
Iced Tea $4
Soda Water $2
Hot
French Press Coffee $4
Latte $4
Mocha $5
Espresso $3
Cappuccino $4
Hot Chocolate $4
with Marshmallow or Whipped Cream (add $.50)
Tea $4
South African Rooibos
Spiced Chai
Lung Ching Green Tea
Golden Assam
Lemon Verbena
Peppermint
