Ozersky: I see the Best of New York just came out. Do you really stand behind your picks? Are they really the "best"?
Platt: You know my position on passing absolute judgments, especially about food. It's a very subjective situation, and all you can do is give an informed opinion. That’s all Best of New York is. I will say that there were a few things I would have liked to include. There was a superb short rib at a restaurant in Brooklyn called Moimthat I would have liked to write up. There's also a great crispy chicken dish in Brooklyn at a place called Lucky 8 that the editors considered a little too obscure. As a rule, though, I like reading the issue more than writing it.
Ozersky: Me too, except for one thing. I have to say that I was a little disappointed that there was no best burger in this issue. I thought your “best un-beef burger” was a cop-out. What is your favorite burger? Do you have one? Just cough it up, already!
Platt: My favorite burger is Shake Shack. No contest.
Ozersky: What about the contest for best ramen? Was your winner, Setagaya, neck and neck with Momofuku?
Platt: Well, Momofuku isn't really a ramen bar, is it. Setagaya's the real thing, straight from Tokyo, complete with towel-headed ramen ninjas behind the bar, and legions of faithful ramen geeks slurping down bowls of that delicious "shio ramen."
Ozersky: But does that mean their soup is better? What do I care if it's more authentic?
Platt: Yes, that means the broth is better. What do you know about ramen, Mr. Pork Chop?!?
Ozersky: What do you think the broth is made of? Speaking of pork, I had to wonder at you picking Adour. In a city with so much great bacon, sausage, char siu, chops, and all the rest, I find it hard to believe that ultrarefined number there could be the best.
Platt: It's a matter of taste, Cutty! The Adour dish combines all the thing you pork fiends crave: artisanal flavor, good old-time fattiness (there's a little stamp of candied belly on the side), and a wheel of loose, handmade boudin noir thrown in.
Ozersky: I'm glad I didn't have to write that one. I think my brain would have exploded. I'm glad, too, that I didn't have to do the lasagne category. Marco's is fantastic, but so is the mushroom-driven version at Fiamma.
Platt: I didn't like the Fiamma lasagne much. I dimly recall it being sludgy and brown and weirdly sweet. In my humble opinion, the lasagne verdi at Insieme is a more faithful gourmet iteration of this great family dish.
Ozersky: What about the part where you pick your favorite new restaurant? Did you and Gail and the Robs divvy that up? Was Dovetail your real pick, or did you cede another place to one of them?
Platt: It does sound like we divvied them up, but Dovetail was my real pick. I liked the unlikely location, and the range of the cooking. Also it's the last good restaurant I've dined at. After a month or two my memory fades.
Most Viewed Stories
Lauren Graham Drinks Wine at Lunch Because It’s Christmastime
Mission Chinese Food Made a Triumphant Return to the Lower East Side Last Night
Paul Bocuse’s Tattoo Selfie Is Just Outstanding
A Customer Tipped a Whataburger Worker With a $10K Fur Coat
Hellmann’s Calls Off Its Legal Attack on Vegan ‘Mayonnaise’
Mission Chinese Food Made a Triumphant Return to the Lower East Side Last NightAll openings »
Café Edison Will Close This SundayAll closings »
Search by name
Or, search by
Stories Elsewhere You Might Like
Well + Good
Your Yoga Prescription: How to beat holiday stress
5 Beautiful Spots in Cuba
Macarons: Don't Confuse Them With Macaroons
Dig Into Sasha and Malia Obama's Favorite Cauliflower Mac and Cheese
powered by PubExchange
Latest News on Grub StreetMission Chinese Food Made a Triumphant Return to the Lower East Side Last Night
The new space has a red hot pizza oven.French Chef All-Stars Plan to Retaliate Against ‘Anglo-Saxon’ Culinary Threat
The first order of business is inviting Steven Spielberg to dinner, for some reason.Caramel Apples Have Been Linked to Four Deaths in a Listeria Outbreak
The CDC took a rare precaution and issued a statement advising consumers to avoid all commercially available varieties.A Customer Tipped a Whataburger Worker With a $10K Fur Coat
"I said, 'Ma'am, I like that jacket you've got on.'"A Chef Scrapped Plans to Serve ‘Thug Rice’ and Chocolate ‘Blunts’ at a Hip-Hop Dinner
Other items included "blood money sausage."Hellmann’s Calls Off Its Legal Attack on Vegan ‘Mayonnaise’
Start spreading the news.Italy’s ‘Best’ Chef Massimo Bottura Talked About Moving His Restaurant to London [Updated]
"The most important ingredient I have is my brain," he says.Justin Timberlake Drinks at Bandit’s Roost; Taylor Swift Celebrates Her Birthday at Almanac
This week's Celebrity Settings.Modernist Cuisine’s Towering Gingerbread House Really Takes the Cake
We're talking laser-etched pastry and Gothic stained-glass windows made from Jolly Ranchers.Lauren Graham Drinks Wine at Lunch Because It’s Christmastime
"And we order steaks the size of our heads."
It would reportedly give one company 80 percent of sales.What to Eat at the West Village Outpost of Jack’s Wife Freda, Opening Tomorrow
New menu items!World’s Most Adorable Couple Celebrates 64th Wedding Anniversary With Taco Bell Nacho Party
That included 64 inches of nachos.Morgenstern’s Unveils New Pies and Holiday Desserts
Pine-nut pie! Date-caramel bread!Genuine Havana Club Is One Step Closer to a U.S. Rollout
Just in time for the ten-year re-release of 'Dirty Dancing: Havana Nights.'Pizza Hut’s American Pies Are Somehow 70 Percent Saltier Than Their International Counterparts
1,080 milligrams of sodium for every 3.5 ounces of pie.A New Lawsuit Claims Whole Foods’ ‘Store-Baked’ Bread Is Anything But
Acme’s and Wegmans’s, too.A Paleo Chef Has Been Accused of Deleting Anti-Paleo Facebook Posts
Disparaging words might interfere with his line of "Paleo is the new black" t-shirts.Desperate Shoppers Will Buy 2 Million Starbucks Gift Cards on Christmas Eve
That's 1,400 cards sold per minute.Totally Awesome Scientists Discover Magnets Can Prevent Unwanted Beer Spew
Scientists say they keep the natural carbonation in check.
At Little Park, Tuome, Upland, and more.He’Brew’s First Hanukkah Ale: 8 Malt Styles, 8 Hop Varieties, and 8 Percent ABV
It's called "Chanukah, Hanukkah: Pass the Beer."Why It Was a Very Good Year for Ample Hills’ Ice Cream
Brian Smith opened a massive new shop, released a cookbook, and began making inroads into becoming a major national player.MasterChef Junior Finale Recap: All the Marbles
It's salt-crusted branzino versus modernist raspberries.America Will Finally Get Its Very Own Pac-Man-Themed Restaurant
These lines could be awful.Café Edison Will Close This Sunday
The plan is to stay open that night "until the last person leaves."Paul Bocuse’s Tattoo Selfie Is Just Outstanding
The 88 year-old chef won Facebook.America’s Most Patriotic Barbecue Joint Plays the National Anthem Every Day at Noon
Some customers start lunch early to be there for the ceremony.10 Places to Snag Some Panettone, the Ultimate Last-Minute Holiday Gift
It looks as good as it tastes.Dinner at the French Laundry Is Now a Lottery Prize
With a "special personal gift" from Thomas Keller.
Workers scrubbed off non-halal labels and put new ones on, an indictment says.Nashville Favorite Rolf and Daughters Will Pop Up at Momofuku Ssäm Bar
It happens January 20.Korean Macadamia Sales Explode After Airline Exec’s ‘Nut Rage’ Incident
The country just can't get enough, apparently.Burger Chain Officially Runs Out of Ideas
McDonald's is desperate to change its image.85 Percent of New York Restaurants Now Have ‘A’ Grades
That's a lot higher than it was when the Health Department's grading system first kicked off.A New Study Says Guys Who Eat Spicy Foods Have More Testosterone
Researchers found alpha males are attracted to the hot stuff.Box Kite Chefs Sign On to East Village Pizza Restaurant
Bruno opens in February.This Rare Butter Costs $49 Per Pound — and It’s Absolutely Worth It
It's Thomas Keller’s absolute favorite, for one thing.Supermarket Sparks Outrage With ‘Ideal for the Food Bank’ Canned-Food Promotion
"Cheap tins are an insult."What 50 Cent Thinks of Manhattan’s Brand-New Cat Café
It happens on the second Tuesday of every month.‘World’s Cheesiest Pizza’ Piles 99 Cheeses Onto 1 Pie
It takes an hour to melt everything together.The Chef Who Instagrams Honest Criticisms of His Own Restaurants
"The arugula is being dressed too much and sloppily laid on the plate."Why Semilla's Einkorn-Buckwheat Bread Is Worth Paying For
Made from a combination of ancient grains and organic flours, its complex flavor speaks to the magic of long fermentation and precision technique.Jamie Oliver Plans to Put His Worldwide Expansion Plans Into Overdrive
The telegenic chef is reportedly recruiting major investors.Britain’s Hottest New Bar Is Inside a Public Bathroom
A local councillor called the plan “bonkers.”Grub Street’s Restaurant Power Rankings: Shuko's Omakase, Mu Ramen's Reservations, and more
Find out where to eat in our weekly ranking of the city's most-buzzed-about restaurants.Heston Blumenthal Drops His Foie Gras Supplier After Seeing Alleged Mistreatment
The video posted online did not fit the definition of "a well-run family duck farm."The Reporter Who Wrote the Harvard Professor Story Sold T-Shirts Shaming Him
"Didn't go the HBS. Also didn't lose my s--t over FOUR dollars."Taylor Swift Lunches at ABC Cocina; Jon Hamm and Edward Norton Double-Date at Claudette
This week's Celebrity Settings.