Dear Grub Street,
Please help explain! Last night three longtime New Yorkers, who have been to their fair share of bars (both at the high-end and the low), encountered one for the books. Cocktail hour found the trio at the bar at the new Bowery Hotel. After three rounds of cocktails, the bill was requested. The menu-advertised price was not the price that was charged: Macallan was $16 on the menu, and we were charged $17; Grey Goose was on the menu as $12, yet we were charged $14 for two of the drinks and $15 for the last one; my first two Scotches were $15 each, and then my last one went down a dollar to $14. Please note: No one's order changed over the three rounds.
When asked for an explanation from the staff, a few excuses were thrown around: We have new purchasing manager who has changed some prices; we have to update the menu; and the final one: WE CHARGE FOR ICE. Two dollars. Each drink. Now call us crazy, but isn't ice part of the deal? Like a swizzle stick and a mixer? We were so flabbergasted by the reasoning, we decided to ask for a to-go cup for our ice … I mean, we paid two dollars for it.
Cold & Peeved in NYC
Most Viewed Stories
Superbugs Found in a Scary Percentage of Meat
A Japanese Ramen Shop Now Has a Michelin Star
What New York Magazine Editors Will Be Gifting This Holiday Season
Meal-Kit Deliveries Are Actually Terrible for the Environment
Renowned Brooklyn Pizzeria Adds 3 Percent Obamacare Surcharge to All Checks
Latest News from Grub StreetAmerica Has Officially Hit Peak IPA
Dogfish Head says it's created the "hoppiest beer ever documented."Grant Achatz’s Next Will Debut a French LaundryThemed Menu
It will "faithfully recreate" a meal that Achatz ate with his father on his first day working at Thomas Keller's restaurant.Get Ready for Star Wars Ice Cream From Brooklyn’s Ample Hills
There are two official flavors: the Light Side and the Dark Side.Renowned Brooklyn Pizzeria Adds 3 Percent Obamacare Surcharge to All Checks
At Franny's menu prices will also rise to pay cooks higher wages.Applebee’s and IHOP Will Eliminate Soda From Their Kids’ Menus
They're the first casual-dining restaurant chains to get on the anti-soda bandwagon.A Japanese Ramen Shop Now Has a Michelin Star
Tokyo's Tsuta joins the coveted ranks of sushi haunts and kaiseki temples.José Andrés to Join Thomas Keller at Hudson Yards
Coming in 2018.The National Restaurant Association Plans to Sue the DOH Over Salt Labeling
The group says the new rule goes too far beyond traditional government oversight.What New York Magazine Editors Will Be Gifting This Holiday Season
(Spoiler alert.)Microbreweries Say Calorie Counts Will Be Ruinously Expensive
They argue "there's no way" they can afford to test every beer.
They're literally full of so much garbage.Even More Retailers Are Refusing to Sell Genetically Modified Salmon
Costco and Red Lobster are the latest ones to pass.This Coffee Shop Just Introduced a Water Tasting Menu
There are notes of calcium and zinc.Utah’s ‘Dirty Soda’ Wars Are Amazing
There is a battle brewing over 44-ounce cups of Dr Pepper spiked with coconut syrup and half-and-half.New York’s Chains to Begin Salt-Shaming Customers This Week
The rule, requiring a scary emblem next to salty food, takes effect on Tuesday.45-Year-Old Vic’s Pizza Closes Tonight
"I'm going to forget it, go to work, find whatever I can find, and that'll be the end of it."Allow Back Forty West to Introduce You to the Fish Rib
Chef Mike Laarhoven cures, smokes, and serves them not with barbecue sauce but a za’atar-spiked crème fraîche.We’re Heading Out to Truss a Turkey
Enjoy the long weekend, and remember to wear pants with an elastic waistband.Whole Foods Again Accused of Selling Meat That’s Not As Humane As Claimed
Animal-rights activists say the company and its supplier are deceiving customers.Details Announced for Alinea’s Residency in Miami
Grant Achatz will cook there from February 17 to March 13.