The ‘Wall Street Journal’ Tweaks Food Bloggers, Unjustly

502 Bad Gateway

Error 502 Bad Gateway

Bad Gateway

Guru Meditation:

XID: 1331998338

Varnish cache server

The Wall Street Journal, having discovered the existence of food bloggers, raises the usual question about them over the weekend, namely: Given that chefs know who they are, and frequently feed them for free, how can their posts be trusted? (The articles other point, about restaurants shilling themselves in online forums, is valid and then some.) But from our point of view, straddling the line between old media and new, we think the bloggers are getting a bad rap.

First of all, the very word blogger, with its slacker-fanboy connotation, is unfair. Bloggers are writers who may or may not make money but practice the same activity of putting words together as do reporters for the Wall Street Journal. Second, unlike most if not all of their old-media rivals, most of the bloggers we know are quite transparent about who they are friendly with and what meals they get on the arm. Andrea Strong, the prototypical food blogger in many ways, used to go on about Katy Sparks so much that youd think they were sisters and never tried to hide her connection in any way. We know most of the top food writers at the New York newspapers and magazines, and other than the critics, if you think that they walk into a restaurant and dont immediately chat up the chefs like old boarding-school pals, youre kidding yourself. And you know what? That conversation is how they know more about food than their readers; its the source of all their usefulness and authority.

Which isnt to say that there arent bloggers who dont go in anonymous, dine on their own dime, and get out (were pretty sure thats how Opinionated About Dining and Ganda Suthivarakom of Eat Drink One Woman do it). But insofar as the bloggers tend to concentrate on the specifics of the food what it tastes like and what it looks like they provide information that everybody, including pro food writers, need. The restaurant world is a more exciting place thanks to bloggers, few of whom are ever going to get rich, or at least get benefits, from their efforts. If more pro writers were half as dedicated, maybe there wouldnt be a need for food bloggers.

The Price of a Four-Star Rating [WSJ]