Tania Zamorsky, for her Pretty Little Head menu. Several readers with an anatomical bent limited themselves to a certain body part, but none were as challenging as just the head, the first thing to go in any butchering process. Kudos also to Tania for a great selection of dishes by a wide range of great New York chefs.
Jen Runnes Caveman menu was brilliant, a sublime tribute to the Ice Age urges that are at the heart of any carnivores appetites. We gave serious thought to awarding her the laurels. Then we realized that four of her courses involved fish and vegetables.
Rodrigo Sanchez. We didnt realize it, but Rodrigo is the brother of Grub Street video star Aaron Sanchez. Rodrigos entry of a nineteenth-century style beefsteak, as immortalized by Joseph Mitchell in his essay All You Can Hold for Five Bucks, touched us to our depths. (The presence of glutton is connected to its past like a tenderloin to a strip.)
Jeff Elliots Hoof and Mouth and Belly of the Beast menus were extraordinarily difficult but had two disadvantages. Some of dishes were from out of town, and others came from second-rate barbecues. As long as Meatopia is being run by Mr. Cutlets, the only barbecue will be from RUB and Hill Country.